Our Team

ThompsonBaker Agency has been serving the St. Augustine community for nearly a century.

Large Commercial

Chelsea Bloom
Account Manager
Chelsea joined ThompsonBaker in 2015 as a Commercial Lines Account Manger. Chelsea graduated with a Bachelor of Arts in Business Administration and Economics from Flagler College and continued with her Master of Business Administration from University of Florida. She holds both the 2-20 Property and Casualty and 2-15 Life, Health, and Annuity insurance licenses from the State of Florida. Chelsea enjoys running and spending time with family and friends.
Robbie Braddock
Account Manager
Robbie returned to ThompsonBaker in 2018 as a Commercial Lines Account Manager and has several years commercial agency experience. Robbie graduated from the University of North Florida with a Bachelor of Arts in Business Administration. He holds the 2-20 Property and Casualty insurance license from the State of Florida. Robbie is a native of St. Augustine and enjoys being active outdoors and spending time at the beach with his family.

Commercial Select

Mariana Uzategui
Account Manager
Mariana joined ThompsonBaker in 2017 as a Commercial Lines Administrator and holds a 4-40 Customer Service Representative License. She is originally from Peru and is fluent in Spanish. Mariana enjoys the new learning opportunities insurance allows her every day, and in 2020 became a Commercial Lines Account Manager. She resides in St. Augustine with her two children, loves going to the beach and spending time with her family.
Erin Elliott
Account Manager
Erin joined the ThompsonBaker Agency in February of 2018. Since joining the agency, she has become a quick study learning the business first as a Commercial Lines Administrator and now as a Commercial Lines Account Manager. She recently graduated from Flagler College in 2017 with her Bachelor of Arts. She currently lives in Vilano beach where she enjoys time spent at the beach with her dog, Noah, as well as spending quality time with family and friends.

Account Administrators

Davis Alexander
Account Administrator
Davis joined ThompsonBaker in 2015 as a Commercial Lines Administrator. He graduated with his Bachelor of Science in Psychology from University of North Florida and holds a 20-44 Property & Casualty Personal Lines license from the State of Florida. Davis is a volunteer Lacrosse Coach at Pedro Menendez High School and active in Boy Scouts of America (Troop 345 – St. Augustine) and enjoys being a member of the Florida Lacrosse League Jacksonville Men’s Team.

Personal Lines

Tracy Trezza
Account Manager
Tracy joined ThompsonBaker in 2018 as a Personal Lines Account Manager. Tracy has earned the Accredited Customer Service Representative (ACSR) and Associate in Automation Management (AAM) designations. She holds both the 2-20 Property and Casualty and 2-15 Life insurance licenses from the State of Florida. Having over 28 years experience in the insurance industry, she has served in many capacities including Customer Service, Sales, Bookkeeping, Reception and Information Technology. Tracy is a native to St. Augustine and enjoys time outdoors fishing, boating, gardening and spending time with her husband and two dogs.
Paula Poulin
Account Manager
Paula joined ThompsonBaker in 2019 as a Personal Lines Account Manager. Paula holds her 2-20 Property and Casualty and 2-15 Life Insurance licenses from the State of Florida. Having over 25 years experience in the insurance industry she has served in many different roles within the insurance industry. Paula currently resides in Palm Coast, where she enjoys time with her 2 dogs Madison & Ruger, as well as spending time with family and friends.
Sherry Petellat
Account Manager
Sherry joined the Thompsonbaker Agency in 2019. Sherry holds both a 2-20 Property & Casualty and 2-15 agent license. Sherry has over 20 years of experience in the Florida Personal Lines insurance market. She is a native Floridian. Sherry enjoys exploring the east coast and time with her family and two dogs.

Jessica Moore
Personal Lines Account Manager
Jessica joined ThompsonBaker as an Operations Specialist before moving into a Personal Lines Account Manager role. She currently holds a 4-40 Customer Service Representative license. Having over 18 years of experience in customer service, Jessica took the opportunity to transition into the insurance field when her family relocated to Florida from New York and is looking forward to a fulfilling career in the insurance industry. In her free time she enjoys traveling with her husband and 2 kids.
Paige Tyrrell
Operations Specialist
Local to the area, Paige joined ThompsonBaker in 2019. She recently graduated from Flagler College with a background in Communications and Marketing. The knowledge and skills gained from her degree have proven to be excellent resources in her integration into the insurance field, and she enjoys the variety this industry offers. In her free time she enjoys writing, going to Disney with her husband, and caring for her pet geckos.
Deb Poemmerl
Receptionist
Deb joined ThompsonBaker in 2019. She was born in Panama and lived in New York until relocating to St. Augustine with her husband, John, in 2019. She has a Bachelor of Arts in Math Education, Masters in Special Education, Masters in Urban Missions, and a Certificate in Culinary Arts. Communication, organization, and cross-cultural skills developed from thirty plus years as an educator and ministry leader are skills she looks forward to using in this position. Faith, family, friends, and food are all foundational to her. She looks forward to spending time with her husband and family, cooking, watching football, walking on the beach, and one day owning a Harley.

Commercial Lines

Davis Alexander
Account Administrator
Davis joined ThompsonBaker in 2015 as a Commercial Lines Administrator. He graduated with his Bachelor of Science in Psychology from University of North Florida and holds a 20-44 Property & Casualty Personal Lines license from the State of Florida. Davis is a volunteer Lacrosse Coach at Pedro Menendez High School and active in Boy Scouts of America (Troop 345 – St. Augustine) and enjoys being a member of the Florida Lacrosse League Jacksonville Men’s Team.

Personal Lines

Tracy Trezza
Account Manager
Tracy joined ThompsonBaker in 2018 as a Personal Lines Account Manager. Tracy has earned the Accredited Customer Service Representative (ACSR) and Associate in Automation Management (AAM) designations. She holds both the 2-20 Property and Casualty and 2-15 Life insurance licenses from the State of Florida. Having over 28 years experience in the insurance industry, she has served in many capacities including Customer Service, Sales, Bookkeeping, Reception and Information Technology. Tracy is a native to St. Augustine and enjoys time outdoors fishing, boating, gardening and spending time with her husband and two dogs.
Paula Poulin
Account Manager
Paula joined ThompsonBaker in 2019 as a Personal Lines Account Manager. Paula holds her 2-20 Property and Casualty and 2-15 Life Insurance licenses from the State of Florida. Having over 25 years experience in the insurance industry she has served in many different roles within the insurance industry. Paula currently resides in Palm Coast, where she enjoys time with her 2 dogs Madison & Ruger, as well as spending time with family and friends.
Sherry Petellat
Account Manager
Sherry joined the Thompsonbaker Agency in 2019. Sherry holds both a 2-20 Property & Casualty and 2-15 agent license. Sherry has over 20 years of experience in the Florida Personal Lines insurance market. She is a native Floridian. Sherry enjoys exploring the east coast and time with her family and two dogs.

Our Partners


IIABA Best Practices
MarshBerry APPEX
Trusted Choice

CSR24

Contact Us

Contact Information

61 Cordova Street St. Augustine, FL 32084 Mailing Address: P.O. Drawer 3807 St. Augustine, FL 32085-3807 Phone: (904) 824-1631